How do I know if my therapist is actually good?
Answered by Dr. Nitnem Singh Sodhi · Mental Health Counsellor, Neuropsychologist & Psychotherapist · Updated 2026-06-11
Short answer
A good therapist listens without judgement, is transparent about method and goals, keeps clear boundaries, and produces measurable change within 6 to 8 sessions. Red flags: no plan, blurred boundaries, no progress markers, or feeling worse without an agreed reason.
The green signals
They can name the modality they use (CBT, DBT, psychodynamic, EMDR, schema therapy — a real answer, not 'eclectic'). They agree explicit goals with you in the first two sessions. They ask about safety and history in a structured way. They hold time, fees and confidentiality clearly. You feel challenged as often as you feel comforted. You can see forward motion within six to eight sessions, even if it is small.
The red flags
No plan and no goals after several sessions. Vague answers when you ask what treatment they are using. Blurred boundaries — accepting personal favours, over-sharing about themselves, dual relationships. You feel consistently worse without an agreed reason. They discourage second opinions or refuse to refer you when the fit is wrong. Any romantic or sexual approach is an immediate ethics violation — leave and report.
How to raise it
It is entirely appropriate to say, in session, 'I don't feel we're making progress — can we look at that together?' A good therapist will welcome the conversation. A defensive reaction is itself information.
Want to talk about your specific situation?
The AI Psychologist trained on Dr. Sodhi's clinical method is free, private and available 24×7 in 100+ global languages.